Their brazen chip-snatching, swooping and aggressive squawking has earned seagulls a popularity because the scourge of seaside cities, terrorising unsuspecting vacationers and enraging residents alike.
And because the marauding birds have ventured inland and established city colonies, cities have deployed spikes, netting and even birds of prey as deterrents. Now Worcester metropolis councillors look like considering a brand new escalation within the battle: chicken contraceptives.
Impressed by experimental pigeon-control schemes in Barcelona and Venice, the Labour councillor Jill Desayrah described the method as “secure intercourse for seagulls”. “I’m involved that the rising numbers of gulls are getting out of hand,” she stated, in line with a report within the Mirror.
Contraceptives have been used with various levels of success as a humane method to containing populations of kangaroos, wild horses, prairie canines, gray squirrels and rats on the New York subway. However specialists are sceptical in regards to the method being a risk-free fast repair.
First, the notion of gulls as an uncontrolled pest species could not match actuality. “Whereas it might seem as if gull species are thriving due to their rising numbers in some city areas, they aren’t faring properly elsewhere,” a Royal Society for the Safety of Birds (RSPB) spokesperson stated. “Individuals can be stunned to study that many species of gulls are red- and amber-listed throughout the UK – the very best ranges of conservation concern – together with herring gulls and lesser black-backed gulls, that are each declining nationally.”
The annual gull inhabitants survey in Blackpole, the realm of Worcester that has been floated as a possible location for a pilot, discovered that 376 pairs had been dwelling on retail parks and industrial estates. The bulk are lesser black-backed gulls, which is a protected species.
“We’d subsequently be involved about any motion taken to scale back productiveness of the birds irrespective of Pure England, the federal government’s scientific adviser and wildlife regulator,” the RSPB spokesperson stated.
There may be additionally the query of efficacy: gulls would wish to take the capsule every day. However with scraps of discarded meals broadly out there there is no such thing as a assure the council’s contraceptive-laced provisions can be favoured.
“Seagulls can eat many issues,” stated Cecilia Soldatini, a senior scientist at La Paz College in Mexico, whose analysis focusses on seabird ecology. Her crew makes use of tacky fries to lure gulls, however the birds refuse fries which have turn out to be soggy within the rain.
“They’re not pressured to eat what you’re giving to them,” stated Soldatini, who has beforehand investigated the usage of contraceptives in feral pigeons in Venice and located the method to be of restricted utility.
Gulls even have a feeding vary of 10-15km (6-9 miles), in line with Soldatini, which means they aren’t reliant on sources from a tightly outlined space. The important thing, she stated, was to eradicate the sources attracting gulls within the first place. “Don’t make meals out there to them, work on the gathering of garbage. That is the one approach.”
Dr Giovanna Massei of the College of York, who’s Europe director of the Botstiber Institute for Wildlife Fertility Management, stated that “exhausting scientific proof” ought to be sought earlier than any rollout – analysis she stated councils must fund in the event that they wished to discover this feature. “For those who put one thing out after which there are many fish and chips mendacity round it’s troublesome for [the gulls] to get the dose they want.”
She added: “I perceive that some councils are determined to discover a resolution.”
Kay Haw, the director of UK Squirrel Accord (UKSA), stated injectable contraceptives had been used efficiently in herd species, similar to wild horses within the US. UKSA is investigating oral squirrel contraceptives collectively with the federal government’s Animal and Plant Well being Company. “There are about 3 million gray squirrels within the UK,” she stated. “You’ll be able to’t catch all of them and inject them.”
Nevertheless, intensive analysis and fieldwork has needed to be carried out over a number of years earlier than the deliberate distribution of medicated meals can proceed. “It’s not a fast course of,” she stated.
A key requirement is guaranteeing the contraceptives solely get to the goal species – on this case by a particular feeding gadget that pink squirrels are unable to function. Haw stated the protein-based contraceptive getting used breaks down so shortly {that a} predator must “eat 1,000 squirrels” to be affected.
“Individuals aren’t essentially as cautious as they have to be about this,” she stated. “They’ve points on the Isle of Wight with pink squirrels being poisoned by rat poison.”
Soldatini agreed that non-eaten meals might pose an environmental threat. “If it rains, it may well go into rivers, or seawater,” she stated. “This identical tablets can have an effect on the populations dwelling there – fish, different birds, sea mammals.”
The squirrel undertaking additionally has a distinct motivation: to help the expansion of pink squirrel populations and the well being of woodlands, not merely to take away a species deemed to be a nuisance to people. “We’re engaged on an invasive species drawback – the [grey squirrels] ought to by no means have been right here,” Haw stated. “That’s a distinct angle to a local species.”
A Worcester metropolis council spokesperson stated: “An annual gull report can be introduced to town council’s surroundings committee on 5 November. This can present councillors with a possibility to think about a gull administration programme for 2025.”
This article by Hannah Devlin was first printed by The Guardian on 25 October 2024. Lead Picture: The notion of gulls as an uncontrolled pest species could not match the fact. {Photograph}: Realimage/Alamy.
What you are able to do
Assist to avoid wasting wildlife by donating as little as $1 – It solely takes a minute.
