Unbiased Temptations Cat Meals Overview

Kate Barrington / Cats.com

Recognized primarily for crunchy cat treats, Temptations now provides an assortment of moist and dry cat meals merchandise. Be taught extra on this detailed overview and discover out whether or not Temptations cat meals is price contemplating to your cat.

The Cats.com Customary—Score Temptations on What Issues

We’ve analyzed Temptations and graded it in response to the Cats.com commonplace, evaluating the model on species-appropriateness, ingredient high quality, product selection, worth, buyer expertise, and recall historical past. Right here’s the way it charges in every of these six key areas:

We give Temptations a 44 out of 60 ranking or a B grade.

Why Belief Cats.com

Having spent numerous hours researching the cat meals business and testing tons of of cat meals merchandise, our consultants are outfitted to conduct in-depth, unbiased analyses of manufacturers like Temptations. Our testing course of begins with a historical past of the model, a deep dive into buyer evaluations, and a overview of the model’s web site and ordering course of.

After deciding on merchandise for testing, we buy them at full retail worth and check out them at house with our personal feline product testers. Our cats provide their opinions on metrics similar to taste, aroma, and basic attraction for every product. Our human testers consider particular person merchandise based mostly on their dietary breakdown, components lists, and different data on the label. We additionally make observations about packaging, price, and buyer satisfaction.

About Temptations

The Temptations model is owned and operated by the pet meals division of Mars, Inc., a worldwide company and one of many largest privately held firms in the USA. The corporate obtained its begin in 1911 when Franklin Clarence Mars opened a sweet manufacturing unit in Tacoma, Washington. The manufacturing unit ultimately failed, prompting Mars to return to his house state of Minnesota in 1920 the place he began one other firm that was later integrated.

As we speak, Mars, Inc. is ranked because the fourth-largest privately held firm in the USA, with greater than $45 billion a yr in annual gross sales. Mars Petcare is the pet meals division of Mars, Inc. and the proprietor and producer of well-known manufacturers like Acana, Crave, Iams, Orijen, Sheba, Whiskas, and Temptations.

The Temptations line was launched within the 2000s with a group of crunchy cat treats and mushy, cream-filled treats. Though Temptations crunchy treats are nutritionally full in response to the Affiliation of American Feed Management Officers’ (AAFCO) nutrient profiles for cats, the model didn’t formally launch a dry cat meals line till March of 2023. Temptations additional expanded its cat meals assortment to incorporate moist cat meals later that very same yr.

Sourcing and Manufacturing

As a worldwide company, Mars Petcare owns and operates manufacturing services all over the world. There are practically two dozen vegetation in the USA alone with a number of extra in Canada and all through the UK.

Mars Petcare doesn’t provide a lot details about the sourcing of components in Temptations cat meals and treats. Nearly the one factor we do know is that the meals is manufactured by Mars, Inc. in company-owned services. All Temptations merchandise look like made in both the USA or Canada.

Recall Historical past

We didn’t discover any proof of product remembers affecting the Temptations model. Temptations cat meals continues to be very new, nonetheless, so it’s price taking this truth with a grain of salt.

Temptations cat treats, which have been round for greater than 20 years, have by no means been recalled both, although there have been a number of buyer complaints, a few of that are severe. Not one of the allegations in opposition to Temptations have been confirmed.

What Form of Cat Meals Does Temptations Supply?

Kirsten McCarthy / Cats.com

The Temptations model is broadly recognized for cat treats, which are available in a big selection of textures and flavors. Having solely been launched in 2023, Temptations full and balanced cat meals recipes are much less plentiful.

As of late 2024, Temptations provides 4 dry cat meals and 4 moist cat meals merchandise. Temptations moist meals are restricted to a rooster recipe and a seafood medley, out there as a pate or bites in gravy. The identical recipes can be found as dry meals with two further flavors.

Right here’s a listing of Temptations cat meals merchandise:

• Tasty Hen Taste Dry Cat Meals
• Tempting Tuna & Hen Taste Dry Cat Meals
• Seafood Medley Taste Dry Cat Meals
• Block Social gathering BBQ Taste Dry Cat Meals
• Seafood Medley Taste Paté in Gravy
• Seafood Medley Taste Bites in Gravy
• Tasty Hen Taste Paté in Gravy
• Tasty Hen Taste Bites in Gravy

Although a number of the product names recommend in any other case, all Temptations cat meals formulation look like chicken-based. Some merchandise comprise complete proteins like rooster or salmon however most additionally comprise some type of animal by-product. Temptations doesn’t provide any grain-free formulation and all of the recipes seem to comprise processed grains like wheat and corn.

What Did Our Check Cats Suppose?

Kirsten McCarthy / Cats.com

To check Temptations cat meals I ordered the Tasty Hen Taste Dry Meals and two moist meals: Seafood Medley Taste Paté and Tasty Hen Taste Bites in Gravy.

The dry meals included pockets (hole kibbles with creamy facilities, identical to the unique Temptations treats), blended in with small crunchy kibbles for an additional tasty shock in every chunk. That appeared to maintain my cat Loki enthusiastically coming again for extra.

The seafood paté was clean and mushy. The rooster bites had been mushy and lined in a soupy gravy that wasn’t too watery. The container has a foil peel prime for simply resealing of leftovers.

My Temptations Meals—High Recipes Reviewed

What Do Clients Consider Temptations Cat Meals?

Temptations is without doubt one of the most recognizable manufacturers of cat treats, with some merchandise on Chewy boasting greater than 12,000 buyer scores. The model’s nutritionally full cat meals are much less well-known, starting from about 130 to lower than 800 scores. Although Temptations cat meals don’t have as many scores because the treats, the merchandise appear universally well-liked—the bottom common ranking is 4.5 out of 5 stars.

Constructive Opinions

Many optimistic evaluations for Temptations cat meals point out that the dry meals is successful with choosy eaters—particularly amongst cats used to consuming Temptations treats or different budget-brand merchandise. Clients additionally love the value level for the model as a complete.

“That is really a pate’ that’s low carb and he gobbles down. Some other pate’ he simply picks over and walks away. He really enjoys this one and it’s extra reasonably priced than the remainder and low carb so it’s a win-win for us.”—Angel reviewing Temptations Seafood Medley Taste Moist Cat Meals on Chewy.com, September 1, 2024

“Our cat could be very choosy. He doesn’t just like the costly meals, he doesn’t like the shop manufacturers or the vet manufacturers, however he love loves this meals. It’s price each penny to maintain him pleased. He doesn’t have or get abdomen points from this both.”—George reviewing Temptations Tasty Hen Taste Dry Cat Meals on Chewy.com, October 10, 2024

Unfavourable Opinions

Opinions for Temptations cat meals are overwhelmingly optimistic however some clients report their cats refusing the meals, even some that take pleasure in Temptations treats. A couple of clients additionally complained concerning the texture of the moist meals or the quantity of gravy.

“I assumed this dry meals can be nice for cats. None of my cats prefer it a lot. They nonetheless love the treats by Temptations.”—Pamela reviewing Temptations Tasty Hen Taste Dry Cat Meals on Chewy.com, September 28, 2024

“After I see “in gravy”, I count on gravy to be within the package deal. Not on this meals. There’s at finest about an eighth of a tsp of “juice”. Which with a really very outdated cat, will not be useful.”—Phyls56 reviewing Temptations Seafood Medley Taste Moist Cat Meals on Chewy.com, September 24, 2024

How A lot Does Temptations Cat Meals Value?

Temptations is a budget-friendly model like Friskies and Fancy Feast with dry meals priced below $0.10 per ounce and moist meals as little as $0.22 per ounce. All Temptations moist meals are offered in 3.5-ounce trays whereas baggage of dry meals vary in quantity from 3.15 to 27 kilos.

The estimated each day price to feed a 10-pound cat Temptations dry meals is lower than $0.25 per day. A moist food-only food regimen from Temptations would price between $1.50 and $1.75.

The place Is Temptations Cat Meals Bought?

Whereas Temptations cat treats are broadly out there in grocery shops, the nutritionally full and balanced cat meals merchandise appear to be extra simply present in pet provide chains (like PetSmart) and low cost shops (like Walmart and Goal). Temptations does provide a retailer locator on the model web site, nevertheless it seems to be targeted on shops that inventory Temptations cat treats.

On-line, you will discover the entire Temptations produce lineup on Chewy.com. Temptations cat meals are additionally offered on-line by the retailers talked about above. Whereas Temptations cat treats are broadly out there on Amazon, the moist and dry cat meals merchandise aren’t.

Total, Is Temptations Cat Meals a Good Selection?

Temptations cat meals is probably going very interesting to cat homeowners searching for a budget-friendly possibility. It may additionally be a simple alternative for homeowners of choosy cats that already take pleasure in Temptations cat treats. Temptations cat meals may not be applicable for cats with meals allergic reactions or sensitivities as a result of all of the recipes comprise rooster and animal by-products (which may comprise protein from a number of animal sources).

When you’re going to present Temptations cat meals a strive, the moist meals formulation are nutritionally superior to the dry meals. They comprise fewer components (particularly processed grains and synthetic components) and are very low in carbs which helps additional enhance their digestibility. For cats that solely settle for dry meals, think about using Temptations moist cat meals as a meal topper or mixer to spice up your cat’s diet a bit of bit.

Related Manufacturers

In search of different cat meals manufacturers just like Temptations? Take a look at a few of our different model evaluations.